Property taxes in Fire Island School District
Fire Island, NY property taxes: median bill $6,098/yr ($508/mo), effective rate 0.54% of home value. That’s 45% lower than the U.S. national average effective rate of 0.99%.
Within Long Island, Fire Island sits 45% below the regional median bill of $11,129. It ranks at the 3th percentile of 121 districts: 97% of LI districts pay more, 3% pay less.
- Median bill
- $6,098/yr
- $508 a month, residential
- Median home value
- $973k
- Most homes $532k to $1.74M
- Single-family homes
- 3,674
- of 4,069 parcels in the district
- Long Island median
- $11,129/yr
- across all 121 LI districts
Where every property tax dollar goes
Most Fire Island homeowners pay $5.28 per $1,000 of full market value in core property tax (county, town and school) for the 2024–2025 roll year. Because this district spans more than one town, parcels elsewhere in it pay a different combined rate; the median bill is computed per parcel using each parcel’s own rate. Village, library and special-district levies stack on top where they apply.
| Levy | Rate per $1,000 | Share of base |
|---|---|---|
| School | $1.227 | 23.2% |
| Town | $2.360 | 44.7% |
| County | $1.690 | 32% |
| Core rate | $5.28 | 100% |
Rates in each town the district covers
| Town (SWIS) | Core rate |
|---|---|
| 472800 · most homes | $5.28 |
| 472200 | $5.65 |
Source: NY ORPS combined county, town and school tax-rate file, roll year 2024. Rates lag 12 to 18 months because the state waits for every town and school district to certify.
How Fire Island compares with nearby districts
Long Island school districts vary about fivefold in median bill. Fire Island sits at the 3th percentile, a lower bill, below the LI median. These are the closest Suffolk County districts by median bill.
- Westhampton Beach $8,085
- Hampton Bays $7,696
- Oysterponds $7,138
- New Suffolk $7,054
- William Floyd $6,696
- Fire IslandThis district $6,098
Long Island median, $11,129
Hamlets and ZIP codes in Fire Island
The Fire Island School District covers 8 or more ZIP codes, nearly all in Suffolk County. Ranked by number of parcels.
Are you a Suffolk County tax grievance firm?
3,674 homeowners in this district can challenge their assessment each year. One advertiser per district and category, no commissions.
Frequently asked questions
What is the average property tax bill in Fire Island?
The median residential bill is $6,098 per year ($508 a month). That is the median across 3,674 single-family parcels in the district. Individual bills vary with assessed value, location within the district, and any village or special-district levies that apply.
Why are property taxes lower in Fire Island?
Long Island property taxes reflect three layered budgets: the school district (typically 60–75% of the bill), the town and the county. In Fire Island, the school rate alone is $1.23 per $1,000 of full market value, on the lower end for Long Island. Districts spend different amounts per pupil, carry different debt, and serve different home-value bases.
How do I lower my property tax bill in Fire Island?
Two main paths. First, exemptions: STAR (every homeowner), Enhanced STAR (65+, income limit), senior, veterans and volunteer firefighter. Second, a tax grievance: if comparable homes nearby are assessed lower, file with your town’s Board of Assessment Review (Suffolk: third Tuesday in May; Nassau: by the March deadline). Grievance firms typically take 50% of the first year’s savings on contingency.
What’s a typical home value in Fire Island?
The median single-family home in Fire Island has a market value of $973,054 on the 2024 New York State assessment roll. The 10th to 90th percentile range is $531,875 to $1,736,527.
Is Fire Island a good school district?
School quality is subjective. For objective measures, see the New York State Education Department’s official report card for graduation rates, test scores and per-pupil spending. We don’t rate schools here; we cover property tax only.
Tracking Fire Island tax rates?
One short email when rates, exemption deadlines or grievance windows change. Nothing else.
Methodology and sources
- Parcels and assessment values: NY State Office of Real Property Tax Services (ORPTS) combined parcel file, roll year 2025. data.ny.gov
- Tax rates: NY State ORPTS county, town and school combined rate file, roll year 2024. tax.ny.gov/research/property. The state publishes final rates a year after the fact.
- Median bill: for every residential parcel we compute a projected bill as full market value × combined county, town and school rate ÷ $1,000, then take the median. This handles districts that span several towns. Village, library and special-district levies are excluded because they vary parcel by parcel.
- District name and code: NY State ORPTS school-district reference file. For official enrollment, see the NYSED report card.
Estimates only, not professional advice. Every figure is derived from public New York State data and is not a substitute for the bill your county or town receiver issues. Outcomes vary with exemptions, special assessments, village and library levies, and changes not yet in the data. Verify with the Suffolk County Receiver of Taxes before making financial decisions.