Nassau & Suffolk Counties, New York Nassau grievance deadline March 1, 2027Nassau grievance deadline Mar 1

Tax grievance

Tax grievance (property tax appeal) — Town of Oyster Bay, Nassau County

91,402 Oyster Bay residential homeowners can file a property tax grievance each year. You file with Nassau County’s Assessment Review Commission (centralized for all Nassau towns). Current deadline: March 1, 2027.

Deadline: March 1, 2027. That’s the statutory deadline. ARC has extended it before (most recently to March 31, 2026), but plan on March 1, 2027 unless ARC announces an extension.

How Town of Oyster Bay grievance works

Even though your home is in the Town of Oyster Bay, your property tax grievance is filed with Nassau County’s centralized Assessment Review Commission (ARC), not with the town. This is unique to Nassau — every Nassau homeowner uses the same county-level filing body.

You file Form AR1 (residential) or AR2 (commercial) either through the ARC online portal (AROW) or by mail. The current filing window covers the 2028/29 tax year — meaning a successful reduction will first show up on your October 2028 school tax bill.

The full process is identical to every other Nassau town. See our complete Nassau County grievance guide for the step-by-step.

Key facts for Town of Oyster Bay grievance

  • Filing body — Nassau County Assessment Review Commission (ARC)
  • Form to use — Form AR1 (residential) or AR2 (commercial)
  • Filing deadline — March 1, 2027
  • Tax year affected — 2028/29 (bills starting October 2028)
  • Filing fee — $0 — grievance filing is always free
  • Oyster Bay residential parcels — 91,402 homeowners are eligible to file

Evidence to bring

The most persuasive evidence in any LI grievance:

  1. Recent purchase price — if you bought in the last 18-24 months for less than the assessor’s estimated market value
  2. 3-5 comparable sales nearby — same town, similar size, similar features, sold for less
  3. Independent appraisal — most useful for unique properties (waterfront, large acreage, recent damage)

Use the live Town of Oyster Bay property data to see median home values and how your assessment compares to neighbors.

Frequently asked questions

When is the Town of Oyster Bay grievance deadline?

March 1, 2027. Filing opens January 4, 2027.

Where do I file?

With the Nassau County Assessment Review Commission. The online portal (AROW) is the fastest path; you can also mail Form AR1.

Can I grieve my Town of Oyster Bay assessment every year?

Yes. There is no limit on how often you can grieve. Nassau publishes a new tentative roll every January, so many homeowners file every year. Grievance firms recommend it because the worst case is no change.

How much can I expect to save?

Typical successful reductions are 5–15% of assessed value, which translates to roughly that same percentage off your annual bill. Real numbers depend on your starting assessment and how much over-assessment you can prove.

Free updates

Get one email when LI tax rules change

Grievance deadlines, STAR limit updates, new exemption laws. One short email, only when something actionable happens. Unsubscribe in one click.

Subscribe

Related

Sources and citations

Last verified November 22, 2026. Tax rules change; we re-check every page each quarter.

Educational content and estimates only, not legal, tax or financial advice. Verify with your county or town receiver, an attorney or a CPA before making financial decisions.