Long Island towns ranked
Click any town for the full breakdown. Effective rate is median tax bill ÷ median home value. The U.S. national average for context is about 1% and the NY State average is about 1.6%.
| Town | County | Homes | Median home value | Median tax bill | Effective rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Glen Cove (City) | Nassau | 6,451 homes | $512,000 | $11,500 | 2.25% |
| Hempstead | Nassau | 204,144 homes | $481,000 | $14,032 | 2.92% |
| Long Beach (City) | Nassau | 7,333 homes | $579,000 | $9,359 | 1.62% |
| North Hempstead | Nassau | 62,144 homes | $739,000 | $20,225 | 2.74% |
| Oyster Bay | Nassau | 90,956 homes | $531,000 | $14,998 | 2.82% |
| Babylon | Suffolk | 54,809 homes | $577,966 | $12,820 | 2.22% |
| Brookhaven | Suffolk | 134,506 homes | $533,333 | $11,701 | 2.19% |
| East Hampton | Suffolk | 18,755 homes | $1,781,250 | $9,488 | 0.53% |
| Huntington | Suffolk | 64,481 homes | $744,444 | $13,722 | 1.84% |
| Islip | Suffolk | 81,611 homes | $576,347 | $12,663 | 2.20% |
| Riverhead | Suffolk | 11,376 homes | $567,402 | $8,522 | 1.50% |
| Shelter Island | Suffolk | 2,485 homes | $1,652,000 | $7,366 | 0.45% |
| Smithtown | Suffolk | 36,943 homes | $678,750 | $15,259 | 2.25% |
| Southampton | Suffolk | 36,644 homes | $1,385,556 | $8,016 | 0.58% |
| Southold | Suffolk | 13,248 homes | $1,090,909 | $9,113 | 0.84% |
How to read this table
- Median home value is the middle home in each town — half are worth less, half are worth more — based on the assessor’s declared full market value on the 2025 roll.
- Median tax bill is the middle bill across the school districts in that town. A single town can include several school districts with very different tax loads (e.g., the Town of Hempstead has 30+ districts ranging from Long Beach to Lawrence).
- Effective rate is the median bill divided by the median home value, expressed as a percentage. For context, the U.S. national average is about 1% and New York State’s average is about 1.6%.
What drives the differences
Three factors explain most of the variation between Long Island towns:
- School district mix. Schools are 60–70% of a typical LI tax bill. A town that includes high-spending districts (Half Hollow Hills, Plainview, Syosset) will have a higher median bill than one anchored by lower-spending districts.
- Home values. Where home values are higher (East Hampton, Southampton, Oyster Bay’s North Shore), the same rate produces a larger bill. East End towns often have lower effective rates but higher absolute bills because the homes are much more expensive.
- Special districts. Fire, library, sewer, ambulance, and water districts each add a few percent to the bill. Some Suffolk towns have particularly heavy special-district loads (waterfront fire and sewer).
Drill down to a specific town
Each town has its own page with the school-district breakdown, ZIP coverage, tax-payment schedule, and links to grievance and exemption guides:
- Glen Cove (Nassau) — 6,451 homes, median bill $11,500, effective rate 2.25%
- Hempstead (Nassau) — 204,144 homes, median bill $14,032, effective rate 2.92%
- Long Beach (Nassau) — 7,333 homes, median bill $9,359, effective rate 1.62%
- North Hempstead (Nassau) — 62,144 homes, median bill $20,225, effective rate 2.74%
- Oyster Bay (Nassau) — 90,956 homes, median bill $14,998, effective rate 2.82%
- Babylon (Suffolk) — 54,809 homes, median bill $12,820, effective rate 2.22%
- Brookhaven (Suffolk) — 134,506 homes, median bill $11,701, effective rate 2.19%
- East Hampton (Suffolk) — 18,755 homes, median bill $9,488, effective rate 0.53%
- Huntington (Suffolk) — 64,481 homes, median bill $13,722, effective rate 1.84%
- Islip (Suffolk) — 81,611 homes, median bill $12,663, effective rate 2.20%
- Riverhead (Suffolk) — 11,376 homes, median bill $8,522, effective rate 1.50%
- Shelter Island (Suffolk) — 2,485 homes, median bill $7,366, effective rate 0.45%
- Smithtown (Suffolk) — 36,943 homes, median bill $15,259, effective rate 2.25%
- Southampton (Suffolk) — 36,644 homes, median bill $8,016, effective rate 0.58%
- Southold (Suffolk) — 13,248 homes, median bill $9,113, effective rate 0.84%
Frequently asked questions
Which Long Island town has the lowest property tax?
Why does the same town have a wide range of tax bills?
Are these the official numbers?
How often are these numbers updated?
See your home’s estimated tax bill
The town median is a starting point — but your specific bill depends on your school district, exemptions, and home value. Type your address to get the parcel-level estimate.
Sources and citations
- NY State Department of Taxation - Assessment Rolls tax.ny.gov
- Nassau County Department of Assessment nassaucountyny.gov
- Suffolk County Real Property Tax Service Agency suffolkcountyny.gov
- NY State Equalization Rates - per-municipality RAR tax.ny.gov
- NJBIA — Tax Foundation: N.J. property taxes still rank highest (state effective rates) njbia.org
Last verified October 29, 2026. Tax rules change; we re-check every page each quarter.
Educational content and estimates only, not legal, tax or financial advice. Verify with your county or town receiver, an attorney or a CPA before making financial decisions.