What we checked
For each property we took its actual 2025-26 tax bill from the official record and compared it with what the calculator works out for the same property from public data: the assessment roll and the tax rates.
The 1,153 Nassau bills are two random samples of parcels drawn from the county’s parcel map, with the school and general taxes each one was billed, read from the county’s Land Record Viewer. The 575 Suffolk bills were read from each town’s own tax lookup or published tax roll. The lists hold tax map numbers and bill amounts only, no owner names or street addresses.
The comparison is with the bill before any STAR exemption: county, town, school, library and special districts such as fire, water, sewer and garbage. That is the number at the top of each property page. Village and city taxes come on separate bills and aren’t part of this check; they’re covered below.
Results by town
“Matched” means within one dollar of the real bill. The other columns count how close the rest came.
| Where | Bills | Matched to the dollar | Within 5% | Within 10% | Off by more |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nassau County (three towns) | 1,145 | 1,097 (95.8%) | 99.0% | 99.6% | 5 |
| Town of Babylon | 62 | 50 (80.6%) | 98.4% | 98.4% | 1 |
| Town of East Hampton | 160 | 155 (96.9%) | 100% | 100% | 0 |
| Town of Huntington | 35 | 32 (91.4%) | 100% | 100% | 0 |
| Town of Riverhead | 53 | 39 (73.6%) | 86.8% | 92.5% | 4 |
| Town of Shelter Island | 18 | 18 (100%) | 100% | 100% | 0 |
| Town of Smithtown | 71 | 61 (85.9%) | 93.0% | 94.4% | 4 |
| Town of Southampton | 101 | 95 (94.1%) | 98.0% | 98.0% | 2 |
| Town of Southold | 74 | 65 (87.8%) | 97.3% | 98.6% | 1 |
| All bills | 1,720 | 1,613 (93.8%) | 98.4% | 99.0% | 17 |
8 more Nassau parcels in the sample are ones the calculator doesn’t price line by line (property in the cities of Glen Cove and Long Beach, utility property, and parcels with no tax district on file). For those the site shows a rougher estimate from state tax rates, marked as such. Of the bills it does price, 95 in 100 came within 0.5%. The total includes 1 Brookhaven bill, too few to show as a row.
Why 107 bills didn’t match
Each one was traced to a cause:
- A charge billed by use (54 bills) — Every tax line matched, but the bill also carried a sewer or water charge that depends on how much the property used, or a one-off charge added to the bill. The calculator estimates the first kind and leaves the second out.
- The bill and the public roll disagree (26) — The assessment changed after the roll was published, a garbage charge was billed for more units than the roll shows, or the district maps put the property in the wrong fire or water district.
- More than one possible set of districts (20) — Where the maps can’t settle which fire, water or ambulance district a property is in, the page shows a range instead of one number. For these the real bill was inside the range. Across the sample, 192 properties got a range, and the real bill fell inside it for 172.
- Exemptions that apply to some lines and not others (7) — A senior or veteran exemption reduces some taxes and not others, and the roll doesn’t say exactly how it was split on the bill.
What this check doesn’t cover
Village taxes. A home in one of Long Island’s 96 incorporated villages gets a second bill from the village. The calculator adds it as its own line, worked out one of three ways.
- From the village’s own assessment or tax roll. Babylon, Farmingdale, Floral Park, Freeport, Garden City, Great Neck, Hempstead, Lake Success, Lindenhurst, Lynbrook, Mineola, New Hyde Park, North Haven, Quogue, Rockville Centre, Sea Cliff, Southampton and Valley Stream post their rolls, and we hold the parcels on them. The line is the village’s own arithmetic: the value its roll gives the home, times its rate, plus the flat charge some villages put on the same bill (Valley Stream’s sewer fee, Lindenhurst’s sanitation charge). Each roll that prints taxable values was checked when it was read: the values we read, times the village’s rate, come back to between 97% and 100.02% of the village’s levy. Rockville Centre’s listing gives total values only, so for a home with exemptions there the village line is approximate. Lynbrook numbers its lots its own way, so its roll is matched to each home by street address.
- Assessed value times the village’s rate, where a village taxes on the same assessment roll the county or town uses.
- The home’s share of the village’s tax levy, for the rest: villages that keep a roll of their own that we don’t hold yet, or whose rate we haven’t read. The levy comes from the village’s adopted budget for this year where we have read it, and otherwise from the State Comptroller’s table of what each village levied the year before.
The share is the weakest of the three, and we have measured it. For 106 homes in our sample of real bills that sit in 6 villages whose rolls we hold, we priced the village line both ways. A plain share came out a median 12.5% above the real village tax: within 15% for 57 of the 106, more than 25% over for 27. Business and utility property carries more of a village’s levy than its value on the county roll suggests, so houses get too much of it.
So a house’s share is now lowered where we could measure by how much. Across all 49,699 homes found on 8 Nassau village rolls, a plain share overstated the homes by 8% to 21%, more in villages with more business property. The correction follows that pattern. Tested on each of those villages with it left out of the fitting, it was typically off by about 4% and by 7% at worst. On the same 106 sample homes the corrected share has a median 1.2% over, with 74 within 15% and 92 within 25%; those homes’ villages were part of the fitting, so that is a best case. It is applied to houses in Nassau villages that keep their own roll. It is not applied in Suffolk, where four villages are now measured (from under 1% to 9% over), so house lines in Suffolk share villages still lean a little high. Business property keeps a plain share, which by the same arithmetic runs low.
Some villages tax homes at a lower rate than other property (two rates, “homestead” and “non-homestead”). There a share of the whole levy is far off for a house: it ran 41% high across Mineola’s homes and 58% high across Lake Success’s. Both are now priced from their rolls, as are Great Neck, Farmingdale and Sea Cliff. Where a two-rate village posts its budget but not its roll (Westbury), a house gets its share of the part of the levy the budget raises from homes, by its part of the value of all the village’s homes. Checked against the Mineola and Lake Success rolls, that came out 2% and 1% high for the homes as a whole. The state’s list of two-rate villages also names Williston Park and Russell Gardens; we haven’t found their two rates, so if they still use them, house lines there are too high.
So far 33 villages are priced from their 2026-27 budgets (18 of them from the village’s own assessment roll), 62 from the latest levy each reported to the State Comptroller (2025-26 for nearly all), a year behind, and 1 (Islandia) charges homes no village tax; each property page says which.
Glen Cove and Long Beach. The two cities bill their own taxes and aren’t priced line by line yet.
Brookhaven and Islip. Both are priced line by line from the towns’ rate sheets like the other Suffolk towns, but we haven’t yet checked them against a sample of real bills: Brookhaven (1) and Islip (none).
Your STAR savings and other personal exemptions. The check is of the bill before STAR. Property pages show the STAR amount for the school district separately, and apply the senior, veteran and other exemptions the assessment roll records for the home.
What a buyer will pay. The estimates of a bill after a sale, and of what a home would sell for, are projections. Nothing on this page measures them.
Check it against your own bill
Look up your address on the home page and compare the result with your bill. Each town page links to the town’s official site, where the receiver of taxes shows the bill on file. If the two differ by more than a few dollars and it isn’t one of the reasons above, tell us: a wrong district on one street usually means the same mistake on its neighbors, and we fix those.
How the bill is built, line by line, is on How the estimate works.
Frequently asked questions
Is the estimate my official tax bill?
No. It is our calculation from public records: the assessment roll and the published tax rates. Your official bill comes from your town’s receiver of taxes (or your city or village), and that is the one to pay from.
Why is my bill lower than the estimate?
Usually STAR. The headline figure is the bill before any STAR exemption, because many owners now get STAR as a check from the state instead of a reduction on the bill. If your bill shows a STAR exemption, subtract it; the property page lists the amount for your school district.
Does the estimate include village taxes?
Yes, as a separate line, and the page says how that line was worked out: from the village’s own assessment roll where we hold it, and otherwise as an estimate from the village’s tax levy. The village sends its own bill, in most villages around June.
Which tax year are these results for?
The 2025-26 bills: school taxes billed in fall 2025 and general taxes billed in January 2026 in Nassau, and the bills Suffolk towns sent in December 2025. We run the check again when each new year’s rates are loaded.
How were the sample properties chosen?
In Nassau, at random from the county’s parcel map, separately from the homes used to work out the tax districts. In Suffolk, homes from each town’s tax lookup or published roll. The Nassau sample also includes vacant lots and commercial property.
Sources and citations
- Nassau County Department of Assessment — Land Records Viewer (LRV) lrv.nassaucountyny.gov
- NY State Open Data — Property Assessment Data data.ny.gov
Last verified November 10, 2026. Tax rules change; we re-check every page each quarter.
Educational content and estimates only, not legal, tax or financial advice. Verify with your county or town receiver, an attorney or a CPA before making financial decisions.