Property taxes in Shelter Island, NY 11964
ZIP 11964 (Shelter Island) has 965 parcels in Suffolk County, including 684 single-family homes. The median home is valued at $1,371,000.
- Median home value
- $1.37M
- Most homes $826k to $2.96M
- Single-family homes
- 684
- of 965 parcels
- School districts
- 5
- serving this ZIP code
School districts in ZIP 11964
Homes in Shelter Island (11964) are zoned into these school districts. The school portion is typically 60–75% of the bill, so the district on your tax bill matters more than the ZIP on your mail.
- Shelter Island932 parcels in this ZIP $9,814932 parcels
- William Floyd9 parcels in this ZIP $6,6969 parcels
- Greenport5 parcels in this ZIP $9,0305 parcels
- Mattituck-Cutchogue4 parcels in this ZIP $10,0504 parcels
- Southold4 parcels in this ZIP $9,8744 parcels
Towns in ZIP 11964
- Shelter Island 932 parcels
- Brookhaven 15 parcels
- Southold 14 parcels
- Hempstead 3 parcels
- Smithtown 1 parcels
Frequently asked questions
What is the average property tax in Shelter Island, NY 11964?
It depends on the school district. Within one ZIP code, bills can differ two- or threefold between districts. Use the property tax calculator for an estimate on any address.
What county is ZIP 11964 in?
ZIP 11964 is in Suffolk County.
How do I lower property taxes in this ZIP code?
Apply for every exemption you qualify for (STAR, Enhanced STAR, senior, veterans) and consider a tax grievance if comparable homes nearby are assessed lower than yours.
Tracking property tax in Shelter Island (11964)?
One short email when rates, exemption deadlines or grievance windows change.
Methodology and sources
- Parcels and assessment values: NY State Office of Real Property Tax Services (ORPTS) combined parcel file, roll year 2025.
- ZIP to hamlet names: USPS ZIP code areas and Long Island hamlet names.
Estimates only, not professional advice.