ZIP 11964 (Shelter Island) contains 965 parcels in Suffolk County, including 684 single-family homes. The median home value is $1,371,000.
Residents in Shelter Island (11964) are zoned across these school districts. The school portion of property tax is typically 60-75% of the total bill.
Property tax in ZIP 11964 varies by school district. The biggest factor is which school district your home falls into — within a ZIP, bills can vary 2-3x. Use the property tax calculator to get an exact estimate for any address.
ZIP 11964 falls within Suffolk County.
File for exemptions (STAR, Enhanced STAR, Senior, Veterans) and consider a tax grievance if comparable homes nearby are assessed lower than yours.
One short email when rates, exemption deadlines, or grievance windows change.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click.
Estimates only — not professional advice.