Nassau & Suffolk Counties, New York Nassau grievance deadline March 1, 2027Nassau grievance deadline Mar 1

Town · Suffolk County

Town of Shelter Island property taxes

Look up the property tax bill for any address in the Town of Shelter Island, see what homes here pay, and when taxes are due. The median bill on a home is $7,366 a year before exemptions, across 3,311 parcels and 1 school district.

An estimate of the yearly bill, line by line, from the assessment roll and current tax rates. For the official bill, see the Town of Shelter Island Receiver of Taxes.

Pay or view your bill online
Next due
Jan 10, 2027Combined bill (school + general), 1st half

The button opens the Town of Shelter Island’s official payment page. This site doesn’t take payments.

Median bill
$7,366/yr
Before exemptions; middle half $6k to $12k
Median home value
$1.64M
Most homes $1.00M to $4.30M
Single-family homes
2,514
of 3,311 parcels
Suffolk median bill
$12,219/yr
county-wide, for context
School districts

School districts in the Town of Shelter Island

Median bills by district. The school portion is typically 60–75% of the whole bill, so two neighbors in the same town can pay very different amounts.

  1. Shelter Island3,311 parcels here $7,3663,311 parcels

Suffolk County median, $12,219

Paying your taxes

When Town of Shelter Island property taxes are due

The Town of Shelter Island Receiver of Taxes collects one combined bill for school, town and county taxes, mailed in December and payable in two halves. Dates below, for the 2026–27 tax year, are the last day to pay without a penalty.

BillMailedPay byAfter that
Combined bill (school + general), 1st halfDec 2026Jan 10, 20271% interest after Jan 10, plus 1% each month to May 31
Combined bill, 2nd halfDec 2026 (same bill)May 31, 20275% penalty + 1%/mo interest (from Feb 1) after May 31
ZIP codes

ZIP codes in the Town of Shelter Island

Property tax figures for each ZIP code in Shelter Island.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

How do I look up a Town of Shelter Island property tax bill?

Type the address into the lookup at the top of this page for an estimate of the yearly bill, line by line. The official bill on file and payment history are with the Town of Shelter Island Receiver of Taxes.

How do I pay Town of Shelter Island property taxes?

Pay online through the Town of Shelter Island’s official payment page, by mail, or in person at the Town of Shelter Island Receiver of Taxes (631-749-3338). The next penalty-free date is Jan 10, 2027 (Combined bill (school + general), 1st half).

What is the average property tax in the Town of Shelter Island?

The median bill on a home is $7,366 a year before exemptions such as STAR; half of homes pay between $5,513 and $12,042. Bills vary most by school district, which is typically 60–75% of the bill; see the districts above.

When are Town of Shelter Island property taxes due?

The bill is mailed in December. Pay the first half by January 10 and the second half by May 31 to avoid a penalty. See the due dates above.

When is the tax grievance deadline in the Town of Shelter Island?

Suffolk County towns, including Shelter Island, accept grievance applications through Grievance Day, the third Tuesday in May, at the town’s Board of Assessment Review. See the Shelter Island grievance guide.

How does the Town of Shelter Island compare with other Suffolk County towns?

Compare median bills across every Suffolk County town and district on the Long Island tax map, or see the Suffolk County overview.

Method

Methodology and sources

  • Parcels and assessment values: NY State Office of Real Property Tax Services (ORPTS) combined parcel file, roll year 2025. data.ny.gov
  • Town SWIS codes: NY State ORPTS standard codes that map municipalities to assessment rolls.

Estimates only, not professional advice. Verify with the Suffolk County Receiver of Taxes before making financial decisions.