Property taxes in Middle Island, NY 11953

ZIP 11953 (Middle Island) contains 4,152 parcels in Suffolk County, including 3,142 single-family homes. The median home value is $468,750.

Median home value

$469k

P10 $333k · P90 $646k

Single-family parcels

3,142

of 4,152 total

School districts in ZIP

serving residents here

School districts in ZIP 11953

Residents in Middle Island (11953) are zoned across these school districts. The school portion of property tax is typically 60-75% of the total bill.

Longwood $9,972/yr · 4,046 parcels
Riverhead $8,948/yr · 13 parcels
Sachem $9,968/yr · 9 parcels
William Floyd $6,696/yr · 6 parcels
Brentwood $8,162/yr · 5 parcels

Towns covered by ZIP 11953

Brookhaven 4,097 parcels
Islip 14 parcels
Southold 12 parcels
Babylon 11 parcels
Riverhead 9 parcels

Frequently asked questions

What is the average property tax in Middle Island, NY 11953?

Property tax in ZIP 11953 varies by school district. The biggest factor is which school district your home falls into — within a ZIP, bills can vary 2-3x. Use the property tax calculator to get an exact estimate for any address.

What county is ZIP 11953 in?

ZIP 11953 falls within Suffolk County.

How do I lower property taxes in this ZIP?

File for exemptions (STAR, Enhanced STAR, Senior, Veterans) and consider a tax grievance if comparable homes nearby are assessed lower than yours.

Tracking property tax in Middle Island (11953)?

One short email when rates, exemption deadlines, or grievance windows change.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Methodology & sources

Parcels and assessment values: NY State Office of Real Property Services (ORPS) combined parcel file, roll year 2025.
ZIP-hamlet mapping: USPS ZIP code area + LI hamlet locality database.

Estimates only — not professional advice.