Cheapest school districts on Long Island
The 25 Long Island school districts with the lowest median property tax bills. Ranked cheapest to most expensive using the latest NY State assessment roll. Excludes tiny K-6 elementary-only districts (under 1,500 parcels) since those families pay tuition elsewhere for upper grades.
- 1 OysterpondsSuffolk County · median home $1.25M Suffolk $6,186home $1.25M
- 2 Shelter IslandSuffolk County · median home $1.65M Suffolk $7,366home $1.65M
- 3 Hampton BaysSuffolk County · median home $735k Suffolk $7,431home $735k
- 4 SouthamptonSuffolk County · median home $2.46M Suffolk $7,652home $2.46M
- 5 MontaukSuffolk County · median home $1.85M Suffolk $7,862home $1.85M
- 6 Westhampton BeachSuffolk County · median home $1.27M Suffolk $7,892home $1.27M
- 7 William FloydSuffolk County · median home $385k Suffolk $7,982home $385k
- 8 East QuogueSuffolk County · median home $941k Suffolk $8,016home $941k
- 9 Fire IslandSuffolk County · median home $1.13M Suffolk $8,046home $1.13M
- 10 Tuckahoe CommonSuffolk County · median home $1.42M Suffolk $8,374home $1.42M
- 11 RiverheadSuffolk County · median home $516k Suffolk $8,522home $516k
- 12 Sag HarborSuffolk County · median home $1.74M Suffolk $8,812home $1.74M
- 13 GreenportSuffolk County · median home $873k Suffolk $8,942home $873k
- 14 SoutholdSuffolk County · median home $1.07M Suffolk $9,113home $1.07M
- 15 QuogueSuffolk County · median home $2.46M Suffolk $9,145home $2.46M
- 16 Mattituck-CutchogueSuffolk County · median home $1.09M Suffolk $9,215home $1.09M
- 17 Remsenburg-SpeonkSuffolk County · median home $1.73M Suffolk $9,251home $1.73M
- 18 Long BeachNassau County · median home $454k Nassau $9,359home $454k
- 19 SpringsSuffolk County · median home $1.51M Suffolk $9,488home $1.51M
- 20 BrentwoodSuffolk County · median home $516k Suffolk $9,488home $516k
- 21 RooseveltNassau County · median home $354k Nassau $9,777home $354k
- 22 East HamptonSuffolk County · median home $1.97M Suffolk $9,887home $1.97M
- 23 WyandanchSuffolk County · median home $437k Suffolk $9,968home $437k
- 24 AmagansettSuffolk County · median home $1.98M Suffolk $10,199home $1.98M
- 25 UniondaleNassau County · median home $401k Nassau $10,243home $401k
Median residential bill, by school district, latest assessment roll. Data and method
How this ranking works
Ranked by median residential property tax bill from the latest New York State assessment roll. For each district, the median bill is the per-parcel projection (full market value × combined county, town and school rate ÷ $1,000) taken across every residential parcel, so districts that span several towns use each parcel’s own rate. Village, library and special-district levies are excluded.
District rankings leave out tiny elementary-only districts with fewer than 1,500 parcels. Families there pay tuition elsewhere for the upper grades, so their bills aren’t comparable.
Built from roll year 2025 data. Cross-check with your county receiver of taxes before making financial decisions.